Source Pravda.Ru

US state Supreme Court to consider whether sperm donor has parental rights

The state's highest court will consider for the first time the constitutionality of a 1994 Kansas law that says a sperm donor has no parental rights unless he has a written agreement with the mother.

The case, which has attracted the attention of legal scholars across the United States, involves an unmarried woman who asked a friend to donate his sperm so she could have a child. He agreed, intending to act as the father for the twins conceived in September 2004.

But the two did not put anything in writing as required by law, and when the twins were born, she went to court to make sure she would be their sole parent. The resulting legal dispute is now before the Kansas Supreme Court.

A group of family law professors contends ruling in the man's favor could dramatically alter how the law deals with sperm donors.

The seven justices plan to hear arguments on Dec. 4 and could rule in February.

Court records provide few details, listing the man only as D.H., the woman as S.H. and the children as K.C.H. and K.M.H.

The twins were born in May 2005. The woman went to court the next day, and a Shawnee County district judge concluded in December that D.H. had no parental rights, prompting the appeal.

"It's caused a great deal of anxiety," said Kurt James, a Topeka attorney representing the man. "He feels betrayed by her failure to live up to her bargain and betrayed by the loss of his children from the time of their birth."

But S.H. contends she intended to be a single mother. She also wanted to know who was donating the sperm so that she would have information about the man's health history, should the babies have future medical problems, Susan Barker Andrews, a Topeka attorney representing her, wrote in her court brief.

As for D.H., he could have sought a written agreement to safeguard his parental rights, even if he didn't know Kansas law required one, Andrews wrote.

"Ignorance of the law cannot result in making one above the law," Andrews wrote.

In a friend-of-the-court brief filed by Linda Henry Elrod, director of the Children and Family Law Center at Washburn University in Topeka argued that D.H. has a "fundamental right to parent" that cannot be abridged without due legal process. Furthermore, she wrote, the Kansas Constitution gives men and women equal rights "in the possession of their children."

That means, she said, the 1994 law is unconstitutional, reports AP.

Also, Elrod wrote, "Kansas public policy seeks to ensure that children have two parents to support them."

But 21 professors of family law, led by Hollinger, replied in another friend-of-the-court brief that the Kansas law ought to be upheld. Participants' institutions included the University of Baltimore, Michigan State University, Ohio State University, Temple University and Washington University in St. Louis.

Hollinger said that while a few courts have shown some sympathy to sperm donors when legal issues arise, none has said a sperm donor has constitutionally protected parental rights. Kansas and at least 15 other states, including California and Texas, say sperm donors do not have parental rights without a written agreement.

Comments
Venezuela may expect another Panama scenario from 1989
12 signs of imminent war between the West and Russia
Exclusive Interview: Oliver Stone on Venezuelan Election
Russia will not be the only country to use Crimean Bridge
Kremlin wants foreign invaders out of Syria
The Royal Wedding and the Silly Season
Germany responds to USA's ultimatum about Nord Stream 2 project
The Royal Wedding and the Silly Season
The Royal Wedding and the Silly Season
The Royal Wedding and the Silly Season
The Royal Wedding and the Silly Season
Russians massively break traffic rules on Crimea Bridge
International study indicates ways to mitigate the effects of climate change on agriculture
12 signs of imminent war between the West and Russia
The Royal Wedding and the Silly Season
12 signs of imminent war between the West and Russia
12 signs of imminent war between the West and Russia
Argentina suggests Putin should reinstate gay propaganda for World Cup 2018
International study indicates ways to mitigate the effects of climate change on agriculture
International study indicates ways to mitigate the effects of climate change on agriculture
International study indicates ways to mitigate the effects of climate change on agriculture