Source AP ©

Louisiana Supreme Court casts away multiple Hurricane Katrina lawsuits

The Louisiana Supreme Court removed a lot of Hurricane Katrina lawsuits, making clear that the lack of evacuation plans is not medical malpractice.

The 4-3 ruling means that the case of a woman who died in a flooded eastern New Orleans hospital, and hundreds of similar cases, will not need to detour through state review panels before trials can be scheduled. Reviews needed for malpractice suits can take up to a year.

The decision reverses an appeal court ruling that said such claims amount to malpractice because they involve decisions affecting patient care.

Althea Lacoste walked into Methodist Hospital with her portable ventilator on Aug. 28, 2005, one day before Katrina struck. She died before rescuers could reach the flooded, powerless building in eastern New Orleans.

Her sons, Stephen and Neal, contended that general negligence law applies to the case, not malpractice law.

The majority of the court agreed.

A lack of any evacuation plan at all or failure to make sure a building is safe from floods "is not `treatment related' or the result of a dereliction of professional medical skill," Chief Justice Pascal Calogero wrote.

Calogero also noted that no doctor, nurse or other health care provider was accused of anything, and "the hospital's decisions affected all persons present in the hospital whether employee, patient or visitor."

The dissent, by Justice Jeanette Knoll, said the case should be heard as a malpractice claim.

"Clearly and most telling, Mrs. LaCoste died from the condition for which she was admitted because of lack of treatment and not because she suffered from any independent injury," Knoll wrote.

Comments
Moving inexorably towards war
Russians lose faith in their future, get ready for worse
Sanctions do not stop foreign countries from buying Russia's S-400 systems
Sanctions do not stop foreign countries from buying Russia's S-400 systems
Russians lose faith in their future, get ready for worse
Russians lose faith in their future, get ready for worse
Putin dislikes the idea of US army bases coming to Kuril Islands
NATO to build prestrike staging base in Georgia
NATO to build prestrike staging base in Georgia
The difference between Polish and Ukrainian nationalism is plain to see
Sanctions do not stop foreign countries from buying Russia's S-400 systems
Sanctions do not stop foreign countries from buying Russia's S-400 systems
Russia rips its economy apart with help from the West
Hillary in 2020?
NATO to build prestrike staging base in Georgia
Russia close to recognising Donetsk and Luhansk republics after Donbass elections
World honours bravery and courage of Russian pilot who killed himself in Syria
USA plays to pretend a mighty dragon that can no longer breathe fire
Russia unveils nuclear-powered interstellar spaceship
USA plays to pretend a mighty dragon that can no longer breathe fire
USA plays to pretend a mighty dragon that can no longer breathe fire