Source Pravda.Ru

Al-Arian verdict shows Patriot Act not a "magic bullet"

The U.S. government's failure to convict a former college professor accused of being a key figure in a Palestinian terrorist group underscores the difficulty federal prosecutors face in bringing Patriot Act evidence into the criminal courts.

In a stunning blow to the government, Sami Al-Arian, who was fired from the University of South Florida after his indictment in February 2003, was acquitted of nearly half the federal charges against him, and the jury deadlocked on the rest. More than 80 witnesses testified over five months of trial.

"I think it's a setback for the government, and I think it might illustrate that the Patriot Act might not be the magic bullet prosecutors thought it was when it was passed," said John J. Farmer, a former New Jersey attorney general and federal prosecutor who served on the commission that investigated the Sept. 11, 2001, terrorist attacks.

Al-Arian's indictment had been hailed by the government as a triumph of the Patriot Act, which for the first time allowed secret wiretaps and other intelligence collected over nine years to be used to charge Al-Arian and others with supporting the Palestinian Islamic Jihad. Before the act, it was more difficult for prosecutors to get access to information gathered by intelligence agents.

The government said the law allowed them to tear down the North American cell of the notorious PIJ and prosecute the kingpins. Critics said the Patriot Act gave government agents the power to overstep their bounds and persecute a man who was nothing more than a vocal activist for the Palestinian cause.

Farmer said the verdicts call into question the ability of prosecutors to use the secretly gathered intelligence as evidence in a criminal case. He noted that intelligence investigations are not designed to provide proof beyond a reasonable doubt, which is the standard in a criminal court.

In this case, the intelligence was presented to jurors in the form of hundreds of transcripts of telephone calls and faxes in which Al-Arian and his co-defendants discussed the mission and future of the terrorist group, and appeared to celebrate suicide bombings that killed Israelis.

Jurors said there was plenty of evidence, but none it linked Al-Arian and the others directly to violent acts of the PIJ on the other side of the world.

The U.S. Department of Justice said Wednesday it hasn't decided if Al-Arian will be retried on the charges on which the jury couldn't decide, including three key conspiracy counts. "We remain focused on the important task at hand, which is to protect our country through our ongoing vigorous prosecution of terrorism cases," the agency said in a statement. "While we respect the jury's verdict, we stand by the evidence we presented in court against Sami Al-Arian and his co-defendants."

Al-Arian remained jailed Wednesday, while prosecutors decide on whether to retry him on the deadlocked charges. His attorneys did not immediately return a call seeking comment, reported AP. P.T.

Representatives of the North Korean administration issued a statement saying that the United States and its allies have lost the "political and military confrontation" to the DPRK

North Korea declares victory over USA

In recent years, genetics has become a cutting-edge science, not only in the professional field of biology, but also because of the enormous social reach of its discoveries and approaches. Not in vain, practically every day the press offers us the discovery of a new gene, a new hereditary determinant directly involved in the manifestation of diseases or physical characteristics.

The Myth of the Gene: Genetics, Epigenetics and the Organism-Environment Loop
Comments
Putin in Egypt: Who's the big player in the Middle East?
Kim Jong-un's tactic of hard power teaches USA lesson of obedience
Russia leaves Syria, but USA stays, to spend some more
Turkey's Erdogan urges others to recognise Jerusalem as capital of Palestine
US military men depressed over of Russia's new T-5000 sniper rifle
Donbass without militia will be worse than Srebrenica - Putin
Putin to Sobchak: We will never let them turn Russia into another Ukraine
Putin makes first comment on Trump's Jerusalem decision
North Korea declares victory over USA
Tel Aviv, Jerusalem, capitals and puppets
Putin to Sobchak: We will never let them turn Russia into another Ukraine
Kim Jong-un's tactic of hard power teaches USA lesson of obedience
Putin to Sobchak: We will never let them turn Russia into another Ukraine
Putin to Sobchak: We will never let them turn Russia into another Ukraine
North Korea declares victory over USA
Putin to Sobchak: We will never let them turn Russia into another Ukraine
Donbass without militia will be worse than Srebrenica - Putin
USA no longer wants Bashar Assad to go
Putin to Sobchak: We will never let them turn Russia into another Ukraine
North Korea declares victory over USA
Visit to Moscow: Tillerson takes secret offer for Putin