Brexit and the issue of EU citizenship
As an individual and independent legal personality, the European Union and citizenship of it is an individual right and cannot be revoked by a single State.
If citizenship of the European is an individual right, is disconnected from nationality, and if EU citizenship and national citizenship are two distinctly different legal personalities, then whether or not the United Kingdom belongs to the European Union bears no influence whatsoever on the EU citizenship of British citizens in the EU or EU citizens in the UK.
Examining the legal documentation and precedent, we see that EU citizenship is supra-national in nature, meaning that Brexit cannot strip British nationals currently enjoying EU citizenship of their acquired rights.
The documentation and precedent
Under the European Union Charter of Fundamental Rights it is stated that the European Union was formed to foster unity and synergies among the European family of nations. In its Article 2, the importance of "pluralism" is stressed;
In Article 3, Paragraph 2: "The Union shall offer its citizens an area of freedom, security and justice without internal frontiers, in which the free movement of persons is ensured in conjunction with appropriate measures with respect to external border controls, asylum, immigration and the prevention and combating of crime";
Idem, Paragraph 5: "the Union shall uphold and promote its values and interests and contribute to the protection of its citizens". Therefore, the legal entity "citizen" is clearly defined. In Title II, Provisions on Democratic Principles, Article 9, it is stated: "In all its activities, the Union shall observe the principle of the equality of its citizens, who shall receive equal attention from its institutions, bodies, offices and agencies. Every national of a Member State shall be a citizen of the Union. Citizenship of the Union shall be additional to and not replace national citizenship".
In this case, EU citizenship is not dependent on nationality, being a separate legal personality and therefore cannot be revoked by an individual State. Established by the Treaty of Maastricht in 1992, EU citizenship has a political legal personality, not a national one and therefore whether or not the United Kingdom leaves the EU, its citizens cannot be deprived of their EU citizenship, meaning that their rights must continue as they are as of any future date on which the UK leaves the Union.
Furthermore, the Court of Justice of the European Union states that citizenship of the European Union is a "fundamental statute" of nationals of EU member states and this means therefore that Brexit cannot constitute a collective loss of rights already acquired. Once a right has been conceded and accepted, the statute assumes a permanent nature.
This Court has gradually widened the scope of EU citizenship in relation to national citizenship by imposing certain limits to the power of Member States to regulate national citizenship. Looking at legal precedent, the Zhu and Chen case underlined circumstances in which the basic rights of EU citizenship need to be asserted against, or independently to, the status of national citizenship.
Professionals working in this area need to take up this issue with the competent authorities to make sure that the European Project is protected and that this first test case concerning the fundamental and acquired rights of European citizens upholds the ideals of the European Union. Up until and as of the date on which Brexit eventually happens, if unfortunately it does, then nothing in the process affects European Citizenship rights of those who wish to have these enforced.
Timothy Bancroft-Hinchey works in the area of teaching, consultancy, coaching, translation, revision of texts, copy-writing and journalism. Director and Chief Editor of the Portuguese version of Pravda.Ru since 2002, and now Co-Editor of the English version, he contributes regularly to several other publications in Portuguese and English. He has worked in the printed and online media, in daily, weekly, monthly and yearly magazines and newspapers. A firm believer in multilateralism as a political approach and multiculturalism as a means to bring people and peoples together, he is Official Media Partner of UN Women, fighting for gender equality and Media Partner with Humane Society International, promoting animal rights. His hobbies include sports, in which he takes a keen interest, traveling, networking to protect the rights of LGBTQI communities and victims of gender violence, and cataloging disappearing languages, cultures and traditions around the world. A keen cook, he enjoys trying out different cuisines and regards cooking and sharing as a means to understand cultures and bring people together.
Join the most international forum on the Net
Turkey has found itself in a circle of countries subject to US and European sanctions. Are they dangerous for Ankara? What is Turkey going to do in response?