Society » Real life stories
Author`s name Alex Naumov

Consumer’s heartburn cost Coca-Cola only 110 dollars

Last Friday a city court in Khimky, Moscow region, ruled that Coca-Cola should pay 3,133 rubles ($110) in damages to Natalya Kashuba. Kashuba filed a lawsuit for damages against Coca-Cola. The plaintiff maintained the company had failed to provide her with complete consumer information regarding usage instructions and potential health risks for a product. Therefore, the company has allegedly broken the Russian law “On the protection of consumers’ rights.”

The hearings in the case began last November. Natalya Kashuba’s lawsuit says the plaintiff developed a health problem due to cola. She began suffering from stomach pain and heartburn. In a hospital she diagnosed a disease with which the use of carbonated soft drinks is not recommended. The doctors told her that she had a non-erosive kind of gastro-esophageal reflux condition. According to medical statistics, at least one fourth of the Russians have heartburn – one of the major signs of the above condition.

Speaking during a court session, an expert confirmed that Coca-Cola soft drinks should not be used by patients diagnosed with the condition. According to him, the regular use of Coca-Cola soft drinks will lead to more acute kind of the condition.

Natalya Kashuba estimated the cost of her medical bills and moral damages at 5,133 rubles ($185). Though the court eventually reduced the amount of damages by 2 thousand rubles, Coca-Cola representatives expressed their dissatisfaction about the court decision and said Coca-Cola would appeal.

According to Dmitry Yasin, chairman of the International Confederation of Consumers’ Societies, at times Russian nationals are awarded damages on lawsuits filed against large Russian companies with turnover totaling billions of dollars. However, the situation is different as to damages claimed from transnational corporations. The Russians seem to be reluctant to file lawsuits against foreign companies. The case of Olga Kuznetsova is probably the only example that remains in the spotlight to some extent. Kuznetsova claims 900 thousand rubles in damages from McDonald’s for injuries sustained in one of the restaurants. Kuznetsova spilled hot coffee on her body after a tray with food and drinks got knocked off her hands by closing doors.

“Transnational companies are trying to play by the book. A small number of lawsuits for damages against them can be partly explained by that factor,” says Yasin, in an interview to Gazeta. “The final decision in the case of Natalya Kashuba is yet to be made. You know, it’s pretty difficult to list all possible counter-indications on a product’s packing. In their turn, consumers should pay more attention to their own health,” adds Yasin.

Dmitry Yasin believes the problem stems from certain flaws in the Russian law. “By comparison with U.S. and European packing materials, the Russian-made packing looks rather miserable in terms of design and consumer information. For example, the Russian law does not say that Coca-Cola or Wimm-Bill-Dann must indicate the sugar content on packing, which only has information with regard to carbohydrates. As a result, there’s no way a person with metabolism problem can learn how much sugar he will consume by drinking a bottle of juice or cola.”

Gazeta

Translated by Guerman Grachev

Discuss this article on Pravda.ru English Forum

A year after the constitutional referendum of December 4th, 2016 that saw the victory of the NAY and the blatant defeat of the government front that had proposed the referendum, it can be said with certainty that the trauma for the defeated is now past. But there is still fear in them, not so hidden either...

Italy: Free fall

On December 10, 1948 the Universal Declaration of Human Rights was adopted by the United Nations General Assembly, its thirty articles enshrining basic and fundamental rights guaranteeing dignity of the human person and equality for all, regardless of race, color, creed or gender. A pipe dream?

Human Rights Day: Let us hang our heads in shame
Comments
USA looking for reason to see nuclear weapons in action
Why did Donald Trump recognise Jerusalem as the capital of Israel?
Putin makes first comment on Trump's Jerusalem decision
Russia works on MiG-41 doomsday fighter jet
Russia works on MiG-41 doomsday fighter jet
Russia works on MiG-41 doomsday fighter jet
Mikhail Saakashvili's bumpy ride in politics: From chewing his tie to climbing on rooftop
Mikhail Saakashvili's bumpy ride in politics: From chewing his tie to climbing on rooftop
European Court of Human Rights: Promoting filth and insolence
European Court of Human Rights: Promoting filth and insolence
Russian athletes announce their decision about 2018 Winter Olympic Games
Turkish President Erdogan issues ultimatum to Washington and Brussels
Gorbachev names reason behind crisis in US-Russian relations
Putin makes first comment on Trump's Jerusalem decision
Human Rights Day: Let us hang our heads in shame
Human Rights Day: Let us hang our heads in shame
Human Rights Day: Let us hang our heads in shame
Putin makes first comment on Trump's Jerusalem decision
Putin makes first comment on Trump's Jerusalem decision
Pentagon can not accept Russia's victory over terrorists in Syria
Putin makes first comment on Trump's Jerusalem decision